Date: 2009-01-24 01:47 pm (UTC)
I'm more ambivalent about this. I've very seldom read the books that are being argued about, but I can't agree with Debbie when it turns out (as it did in the latest bust-up) that she hasn't either. That tends to undermine any other argument she makes about authenticity.

On the more general issue - well, I talked about all this at some length in Four British Fantasists and won't go over that ground again here, but one thing I only got to touch on in that book is that these arguments are often at cross purposes. Debbie's attitude towards story, culture, and indeed subjectivity is far more communally grounded than the dominant western model. She comes from a tradition where authenticity is in the gift of the community rather than an existential stance taken by an individual. Hence, presumably (to take a fairly peripheral example), the fact that she puts (Nambe Pueblo) after her signature. Were I to sign myself Steepholm (Anglo-Celtic) it would look like an affectation, but in her case I take it to be indicative of where her sense of self begins and ends. My suspicion is that this difference is where a lot of the child_lit disagreements stem from, and that when they and Debbie argue about autonomy, authenticity, responsibility, individuals, etc, they actually mean rather different things.
(will be screened)
(will be screened if not validated)
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.
More info about formatting

If you are unable to use this captcha for any reason, please contact us by email at support@dreamwidth.org

Custom Text

Gnomic Utterances. These are traditional, and are set at the head of each section of the Guidebook. The reason for them is lost in the mists of History. They are culled by the Management from a mighty collection of wise sayings probably compiled by a SAGE—probably called Ka’a Orto’o—some centuries before the Tour begins. The Rule is that no Utterance has anything whatsoever to do with the section it precedes. Nor, of course, has it anything to do with Gnomes.

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 13th, 2025 03:27 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios